A lot of people are having difficulty getting visas to come to or stay in the U. S. as a result of the recent homeland security legislation. Even if I didn’t agree with Benjamin Franklin that anyone who trades freedom for security deserves neither, I’d be concerned about the unintended consequences.
I think we’re really shooting ourselves in the foot here. A significant percentage of academic faculty members–especially in the sciences–are foreign nationals. So are a vast number of graduate students. Even those who manage to stay in the country may not be able to pursue their research because of new restrictions. And it isn’t just the sciences, it’s the arts as well. Plenty of professional dancers, for example, are foreign nationals. They move from dance company to dance company, all over the world, as well as guest starring in single productions. These people are in the country legally, they have good jobs, and they are dedicated professionals. They don’t have time to get up to mischief, even if they were inclined to do so at the expense of careers that they’ve been deeply committed to for years.
It isn’t just all of these bright and talented people who either can’t stay or can’t get in. Worst of all is the chilling effect on those people who might have decided to come to the U. S. in other circumstances, but don’t want to deal with our immigration policies. They’ll go elsewhere, and it will most certainly be our loss. And let’s face it, if the best and brightest can’t get in or can’t stay, what chance to the decent, ordinary, and hardworking have, let alone the oppressed and underprivileged? We’re going to destroy the American dream by protecting it to death.